Reason Why John Lennon Called A Neil Young Song Garbage?

Reason Why John Lennon Called A Neil Young Song Garbage
Lennon was a consummate artist who disapproved of anything that the band didn’t give their complete attention to. As a result, a song that Lennon saw as “trash” or “throwaway” swiftly dropped to the bottom of the pack.

What did John Lennon think of Neil Young?

George Harrison wasn’t the only member of the Fab Four who didn’t like for Young; John Lennon was the same way. According to Grunge, John Lennon gave his opinion on Neil Young’s song “Hey, Hey, My, My (Into the Black)” during an interview that was conducted in 1980 for the magazine Playboy.

Why Neil Young is important?

Neil Young is a legendary personality in the world of contemporary music. His extensive body of work, which is characterized by a distinctive guitar sound, highly personal lyrics, and a characteristic high-tenor singing voice, continues to have a significant amount of impact on musicians all over the world.

Does Neil Young pay homage to John Lennon?

Both John Lennon and Neil Young were involved. Neil Young gave a performance of John Lennon’s song “Imagine” on the aired musical benefit telethon “America: A Tribute to Heroes” on September 21, 2001, just a few days after the terrorist assault on the United States that occurred on September 11, 2001.

The program was broadcast live simultaneously from London, New York, and Los Angeles on the four main television networks as well as the Internet. It was estimated that 89 million viewers watched it, and it raised around $230 million in contributions. The performance that Young gave was, for many people, one that was emotionally taxing and heartfelt.

Young’s performance of John Lennon’s “Imagine,” which he sang on a grand piano and which was accompanied by a small orchestra of violins, spoke to many of us who were grieving from the awful events that had occurred in New York, Pennsylvania, and Virginia (the Pentagon is actually located across the Potomac River from Washington, DC).

Those who were at the recording studio on that particular evening claimed that once the song was finished, Young seemed to be on the edge of crying. According to an article that appeared in Pulse Magazine, Young’s performance of “Imagine” during the Benefit webcast was “one of those moments you never forget.” The following is an excerpt from Neil Strauss’s article “Waiting for Our John Lennon,” which appeared in The New York Times on September 30, 2001: “Therefore, it came to pass that an executive at Clear Channel Communications was circulating among its more than 1,100 affiliate radio stations a list of songs that were deemed questionable for airplay in light of the attacks, and at the same time, a link to a website started to circulate on the Internet grapevine.

At the location, a snippet of a song that was on the Clear Channel graylist (it’s not quite a blacklist because it’s voluntary) played over photographs depicting the attacks on September 11 and the aftermath of those attacks, with each photograph being perfectly keyed to a song lyric in order to elicit the greatest possible emotional response from visitors.

The artist was John Lennon, and the song was “Imagine.” It didn’t take long for “Imagine” to become the soundtrack of optimism in the aftermath of the tragic events of September 11; different versions of the song can be found on the Internet, and it has even been performed by undiscovered home-studio musicians.

The following passage is perhaps the most compelling argument in its favor: Imagine there are no nations on earth. It is not difficult in any way. There is nothing worth killing or dying for, and there is no religion either. Think about all the people there would be.

Living one’s life in tranquility Since its first publication in 1971, the song “Imagine” has been celebrated as a global anthem, despite the fact that it was written on the back of a hotel bill while the author was traveling by airline. Lennon’s thoughts, on the other hand, are viewed by the song’s detractors as naïve anarcho-communism, a concept that is wholly unfeasible and was presented by a guy who is quite divorced from reality.

However, the fact that “Imagine” has received negative reviews is precisely the reason why songs and other forms of creative expression are essential to society. It constructs an universe that does not exist in the real world by imagining it and, as a result, bringing it into existence.

It shouldn’t come as a surprise, then, that Neil Young, rock’s eternal hippie and fiery man on the mountain, knew exactly which song would be the most poignant to perform on ‘America: A Tribute to Heroes,’ the all-star television fund-raiser that was broadcast on September 21. The show was a benefit for the United States Department of Veterans Affairs (VA).

Those who were paying close attention may have observed that Mr. Young altered the word “you” in the song “Imagine no possessions/ I wonder if you can” to the word “I.” This was done when it came time for him to perform the line. Mr. Young wanted to take some of the air of superiority out of the song by admitting that even he, the self-sufficient mountain guy, would not be able to let go of the material world.

See also:  How To Un Dislike A Song On Pandora?

This was the aim of his commentary. Lennon, on the other hand, posed the challenge in the form of a wise teacher addressing you, the listener and student, as if he were instructing you on how to change the world by first altering yourself. The majority of his songs and catchphrases, such as “War is finished, if you want it,” expressed this message in various ways.

Even his legendary song “Give Peace a Chance,” which is presently being re-recorded by his widow, Yoko Ono, and her pop-star pals, did not place blame on the conventional countercultural antagonist, “them.” Yoko Ono and her friends are currently working on re-recording the song.

Instead, it seemed to be addressing the reader directly. (On Tuesday, John Lennon will be remembered at Radio City Music Hall during an event titled “Come Together: A Night for John Lennon’s Words and Music,” which will be televised live on TNT.) These kinds of sweeping declarations and direct challenges were the solitary John Lennon’s source of talent as well as his Achilles’ heel.

He had a certain amount of leeway to be conceited, quirky, and overconfident in his opinions and his capacities due to the fact that he was a pop sensation and an artist. On the other hand, he possessed the moral fortitude to remain consistent with both himself and his principles, despite the fact that both he and they were subject to constant ridicule and change. (Play and listen to this MP3 sample of Neil Young’s rendition of John Lennon’s “Imagine,” which can be found on the broadcast fundraiser CD titled America: A Tribute to Heroes.) From an interview conducted by Tom Lanham for Pulse Magazine in April 2002 on the feelings that Neil Young had on the evening of ‘A Tribute to Heroes? ‘: YOUNG: “First and foremost, I believe that the very first time that we practiced it was the night before.” Therefore, we went through it around ten times before everything eventually started to come together and we were able to understand what we were supposed to be doing.

  • We did all we could to do the original version credit, including using the original charts from the original album and doing everything we could to do it.
  • We weren’t aiming to do anything other than that.
  • Simply attempting to emulate John Lennon’s style is the goal here.
  • It was just such an amazing tune to listen to at that time.

After the events of September 11, my wife Pegi received an email from a friend of hers with the subject line “Imagine” on it. And it was at the same time that I was trying to figure out what to play since we only had two and a half to three days’ notice before the event was scheduled to take place.

And I saw that as a positive portent of things to come. I just learnt it and rehearsed it, and when we did it that night, everything just fell into place perfectly. Consequently, we went ahead and obtained the lyrics, including the ones that I couldn’t remember. And clearly, those are the nitty-gritty details, but the truly emotionally charged portion is.

To be honest, the reasons behind why things transpired in that manner are glaringly evident. It’s an opportunity to do your job, to do what you do, and have it truly be what it’s intended to be, which is one of the perks of being a musician, singer, or songwriter when situations like this arise.

That’s one of the benefits about being a musician, singer, or songwriter.” The following is an excerpt from the Book Review that was published in Maclean’s on May 13, 2002 by BRIAN D. JOHNSON: “The Canadian from that “town in north Ontario” has blazed a rough path on the frontier of the rugged individualism that characterizes the United States.

He’s known as the reclusive rock star. But when he comes out into the light, there is a vulnerable honesty in his music that has an eerie quality to it. He is like King Lear venturing out into the tempest as he is wailing on his guitar on the brink of an enormous stage.

  1. When he was by alone at a piano at the telethon for the victims of September 11, 2011, he delivered the most personal moment of the evening by performing “Imagine.” Label him as insane.
  2. However, Neil is still capable of maintaining his authenticity.” During the 9/11 Memorial Concert, Neil Young Performed “Imagine.” Since then, Young has given two more renditions of “Imagine” at the Bridge School Benefit Concert, which took place on October 20 and 21, 2001 at the Shoreline Amphitheater in Mountain View, California.
See also:  How To Make A Song Sound Fuller?

Both of these renditions served as closing encores and featured all of the artists. The following is an excerpt from a review written by Stephen Holden and published in Rolling Stone on September 26, 1974: “On the Beach raises philosophical and political issues that are too weighty to be addressed in a light-hearted manner, and as a result, the album’s music has a gritty, uncompromising quality to it.

This helps the record live up to its reputation as a masterpiece. Young recalls fundamental social and psychic opposites that serve as examples of the degeneration of American civilization through the use of a number of opposing personae in his work. The images of Charles Manson and Patricia Hearst appear as icons of catastrophic societal dislocation in the album’s two classics, “Revolution Blues” and “Ambulance Blues.” Although they are not named, the figures appear in the songs “Revolution Blues” and “Ambulance Blues.” Young has dared what no other major white rock artist (except John Lennon) has done: embrace, expose, and perhaps help purge the collective paranoia and guilt of an insane society, acting it out without apology or explanation.

He does this in each song by empathizing with the feelings of both predators and victims.” In the same way that Kurt Cobain’s passing signaled the end of the grunge period, John Lennon’s passing put an end to the love and peace attitude that characterized the 1960s, albeit some twenty years later.

In an interview with John Lennon and Yoko Ono that was published in Playboy Magazine in January 1981 (the same issue featured a nude layout of Barbara Bach, who is married to Ringo Starr), Lennon analyzes Neil Young’s lyrical content as follows: You don’t agree with the line that Neil Young wrote for Rust Never Sleeps, which says, “It’s better to burn out than to fade away.”, do you, Playboy? Lennon: I despise it.

Why Pink Floyd’s Roger Waters was disappointed when he met John Lennon?

It is preferable to slowly go like an old soldier than to completely fizzle out. I find it offensive when people continue to revere deceased celebrities like Sid Vicious, James Dean, or John Wayne. It comes down to the same thing. Putting up Sid Vicious and Jim Morrison as heroes is, in my opinion, complete trash.

I revere those who have managed to stay alive. Gloria Swanson, Greta Garbo. They claim that John Wayne won his battle with cancer and that he handled it like a man. You know, I’m sorry that he died and everything, and I’m terrible for his family, but he didn’t beat cancer. My condolences go out to them.

It beat him very badly. I don’t want Sean to have a hero complex about Sid Vicious or John Wayne. What kind of lessons do they provide you? Nothing. Death. Why did Sid Vicious take his own life? So that we may have a good time? I’m saying that it’s worthless, just so you know.

  • Why does Neil Young not act on that conviction, given how much he values the sentiment? Because he definitely vanished for a while but reappeared on several occasions, just like the rest of us.
  • Not at all, thank you.
  • I’ll take those who are still alive and in good health.
  • The following is an excerpt from an interview that was published in Rolling Stone by Jann Wenner in December 1970: What kind of music have you been listening to recently? LENNON: Since I’ve been in this location listening to the radio, I can tell you that I enjoy a couple songs by Neil Young and one song by Elton John.

If that’s what you’re after, the record bit. There are some pretty nice sounds, but there is typically no follow-through after that. Despite this, there are some really good sounds. You’ll hear a wonderful sound on the radio, and then you’ll wait for the ending, the concept, or whatever else to finish it off, but nothing ever occurs; instead, it simply continues on to a jam session or whatever else it is.

Van Morrison’s music is fascinating to listen to. He is one of those artists that became an American, like Eric Burdon, and he looks to be creating some great work that is reminiscent of black music from the 1960s. Simply said, I never have enough time to listen to an entire record. Even though I’ve only heard Neil Young’s music twice, I can recognize it and his sound from a mile away.

He is the author of some pleasant tunes. I’m not hung up on Sweet Baby, and I’m growing to enjoy him more as I hear more of his music on the radio, but his music has never really impacted me. On two of his albums, Neil Young pays tribute to John Lennon in various ways. We grieve deeply for the loss of you, John Lennon. Your comments and input about John Lennon and the song “Imagine” are much appreciated. Play and listen to the MP3 sample of Neil Young’s rendition of John Lennon’s “Imagine,” which can be found on the televised fundrasier CD titled America: A Tribute to Heroes.

See also:  How To Get A Song From Garageband To Itunes?

Did John Lennon define the essence of Rock ‘n’ Roll?

Since his passing, John Lennon has been held in high esteem all throughout the world, perhaps achieving the rank of a quasi-god more than any other individual. On the other hand, it was precisely this concept that Neil Young’s decision to idolize rock’s departed troops, which the late Beatle found offensive.

  • This cliched sentiment is explored in Neil Young’s classic song “My My, Hey Hey (Out of the Blue),” which, sadly, is now also intrinsically linked to the death of Nirvana frontman Kurt Cobain.
  • Cobain included the line, “It’s better to burn out than to fade away,” as part of his suicide note.
  • Young’s song is now also intrinsically linked to Cobain’s death.

“When he passed away and left that message, it moved me to my core on a very personal level. It screwed with my head, “In a subsequent statement, Young said. “It just so happened that I had been attempting to get in touch with him. I really want to communicate with him.

Tell him to only play when he feels like it and not any other time.” The passing of Cobain had a great impact on Young, and it was in part because of this tragedy that he was inspired to create the album Sleeps With Angels, which he later dedicated to the late vocalist of Nirvana. The song that Kurt Cobain cited in his dying act is a celebration of fallen rockstars who lived their lives in the fast lane and as a result, sadly died at an earlier age.

This is a heartbreaking fact. Lennon, on the other hand, came from a distinct intellectual tradition. He made his disapproval of the lyric public because he didn’t think it was a good idea for Young to utilize his position to promote a lifestyle that he considered unhealthy.

  1. In one of his last interviews, John Lennon shared the following with Playboy: “I despise it.
  2. It is preferable to gradually disappear like an old soldier than to completely fizzle out.
  3. Forget it if he was talking about squandering away his talent as Sid Vicious did.
  4. I find it offensive that people continue to venerate deceased celebrities like Sid Vicious, James Dean, and John Wayne after they have passed away.

It comes down to the same thing. To me, it’s complete crap to glorify Sid Vicious or Jim Morrison as heroes. I bow down to those who have triumphed against adversity, such as Gloria Swanson and Greta Garbo “. Lennon continued: “They claim that John Wayne defeated cancer and behaved like a man in the process of doing so.

You know, I’m sorry that he died and everything, and I’m sorry for his family, but he wasn’t able to beat cancer. I’m sorry for them. It beat him very badly. It is not acceptable to me for Sean to hold John Wayne, Johnny Rotten, or Sid Vicious in high regard. What kind of lessons do they provide you? Nothing.

Death. Why did Sid Vicious take his own life? So that we may have a good time? I mean, you should realize that it’s worthless crap.” In conclusion, he said: “Why does Neil Young not act on that conviction, given how much he values the sentiment? Because he definitely vanished for a while but reappeared on several occasions, just like the rest of us.

  1. No, thank you very much.
  2. I’ll take those who are still alive and in good health.” Young felt obligated to come out and defend the meaning of his composition, which he believed had been misinterpreted by the spectacled Beatle.
  3. This was despite the fact that Young had a great deal of admiration for Lennon.

The Canadian offered this explanation: “To me, the defining characteristic of the rock and roll attitude is the conviction that it is preferable to go out with a bang rather than to gradually fade away into eternity. despite the fact that if you examine it with an adult’s perspective, you’ll conclude that “Well, certainly, you should fade out into infinity, and keep continuing along.” Rock and roll does not seem to plan too far in advance.

The time is perfect for rock ‘n’ roll. What is taking place precisely at this very now.” Young believed that the song was more about the immediacy of rock and roll than it was about anything else, despite the fact that it undeniably celebrates tragedy. In spite of the fact that John Lennon despised the message, Young’s characterization of the core of rock ‘n’ roll was perfectly exemplified by Lennon, which is quite ironic given that Lennon held the position that he did.

Stay up to date with Far Out Magazine across all of our social platforms by following us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.